Giants needed to walk before running over Dodgers

Unknown-7

By Jon Weisman

When Alex Wood took the mound to start the bottom of the fifth inning today at San Francisco, he had a 4-0 lead and a 31-inning scoreless streak by Dodger pitching behind him.

One of the unsung aspects of that streak was that the Dodgers had gone 23 straight innings without walking a batter. Wood had done his part, zipping through his first four innings with first-pitch strikes to 14 of the 15 batters he had faced. Three Giants had hits in three different innings, but each was stranded without much drang, let alone any sturm.

For whatever reason, when Wood began pitching in the fifth, he lost command. His first three pitches to Brandon Crawford missed, and then after getting two called strikes, Wood missed badly for what became the Dodgers’ third walk of the season.

Kelby Tomlinson, pinch-hitting for Jake Peavy, then laid down a bunt that died on the grass just inside fair territory. Suddenly, for the first time all season, a Dodger opponent had two on with none out.

On such little events do seasons make their first pivot.

“If I throw that changeup for a strike (to Crawford), we’re not having this conversation,” Wood said to SportsNet LA’s Alanna Rizzo after the game. “I probably should have just thrown a heater and challenged him a bit more.”

The next two San Francisco batters grounded out, and if this inning had begun like any of the previous 31, it would have ended with the Dodgers tying the Major League record for most scoreless innings to start the season. Instead, Denard Span’s groundout brought home the first run.

And then the pendulum truly swung. Joe Panik tripled, Buster Posey doubled, and no longer were the Dodgers the invincible force that had taken a record 29-0 lead on the National League West. It was now 29-3, and more to the point, 4-3 heading into the sixth inning.

With two out and none on in the top of the sixth, Dave Roberts decided not to waste one of his five reserves (or Kenta Maeda) and let Wood bat for himself in a low-leverage situation. But in the bottom of the sixth, Wood pitched from behind again, and gave up singles to Matt Duffy and Crawford. Then came Yimi Garcia, who had thrown shutout ball in his first two innings of 2016 but couldn’t hold off the Giants from scoring four times for a 7-4 lead. For the first time this season, the Dodgers trailed.

“At 74 pitches, as far as stamina and where he was at, I didn’t see him missing arm-side, I didn’t see him losing velocity, I think his stuff held,” Roberts said of the decision to bring Wood back for the sixth inning. “Duffy hits a ball, seeing-eye grounder through the four hole, and a little jam shot, seeing-eye thing off Crawford’s bat. … It wasn’t like they were taking a bunch of great swings. I think in that last inning-and-a-half, it was two hard-hit balls.”

Joc Pederson’s two-run homer in the eighth cut the deficit to a single run, making the bonus runs the Giants scored ache that much more. In fact, the Dodgers’ offensive start remained very much a thing: Adrian Gonzalez had two doubles and a single, Yasiel Puig had two more laser hits, Chase Utley had a couple of singles, Scott Van Slyke (in his first start of the year) an RBI double that just missed being a three-run home run. Los Angeles began the game with an overt game plan to swing early and often against Peavy, who allowed 10 hits in his five innings, and it worked.

But by the end, the Giants had locked in, adding five runs in the bottom of the eighth off J.P. Howell and Pedro Baez, capped by a Hunter Pence grand slam, and the 12-6 score was made final. The Dodgers’ streaks are over, and the NL West battle has been joined.

9 Comments

Rookie manager mistake letting him no only hit in 6th but to let him finish the 5th (although he kept the lead there).
Howell needs to be DFA, if he can’t get lefties out, what’s the point of keeping him, bring up Libertore.
I’m hoping for a split this series, but I can easily see 1-3.

Rookie mistake? Come on. As if any amount of experience would have affected his decision making in this most basic situation. It wasn’t as if he was under water confused about a double switch or something. He made a decision and it didn’t work out. No big deal, and certainly not a rookie mistake..

I hope he doesn’t make the same choice again, it was the wrong choice, whether it worked or not.

You’re judging the decision by outcome rather than info available at the time the decision was made. You have the benefit of 20-20 hindsight. Go back and read what Roberts said about why he did what he did. If Wood had gotten back on track in the 6th, quite likely you wouldn’t think bringing him back was wrong.

No, I’m not judging by outcome. He should have taken him out in the 5th, even before he qualified for the win. Once he didn’t and they still had the lead, for sure he should have pinch hit for him in the 6th. The history of Wood the third time against a little lineup is bad, this is not 20-20 hindsight, but facts right in front of everyone. It was a mistake, rookie or not, and I hope he doesn’t make it again.

Is Don Mattingly back?

I’m more disappointed in not breaking the Cardinals’ streak than in losing the game

I so love the “kill the manager” meme. Jeez, guys. It’s the fourth game of the season and the first one where any decision-making was required. Think we might wanna chill. I wasn’t thrilled with leaving Wood in, although more so because of the fact that I didn’t like seeing us kind of give up an at-bat in the top of the 6th. But it’s totally justifiable why Roberts did what he did, not only because of the way he was thinking, but also because in game 4 of the season, it might be a good idea to let your pitcher know you have some confidence in him. Remember how irritated Wood used to get whenever Mattingly took him out — I feel like he in particular is a good guy to get a bit of “we trust you to get out of your own jams.” Think Roberts deserves at least 5 games before we start killing him.

I’m certainly not trying to “kill” Roberts. But sorry if people don’t like it, but with Wood’s history the call was to remove him. 4th game or the 154th game, doesn’t matter.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: